Opens in a new tab

NEWS & INSIGHTS

NEWS & INSIGHTS

ADA Website Accessibility Lawsuits: Why the Nexus Requirement Matters for Your Business

  • Corporate
  • Legal Watch
  • LLG News

In Murphy v. Rolex Watch USA, Inc., the United States District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania addressed an important question for businesses operating online: Can a business be sued under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) solely because its website is inaccessible? In March 2023, a legally blind plaintiff sued Rolex Watch USA, Inc. and Rolex SA, alleging that Rolex.com was incompatible with screen reader software used by visually impaired individuals. The plaintiff claimed that the website prevented him from having “full and equal access” to Rolex’s products and services.

Rolex SA moved to dismiss the amended complaint, arguing that the court lacked personal jurisdiction over the company and that the plaintiff had failed to state a valid legal claim.

In addressing Rolex SA’s failure to state a valid claim argument, the court agreed that the plaintiff had indeed failed to state a claim against Rolex SA. The court found that the plaintiff had not adequately connected Rolex SA’s website to a physical location owned, operated, or leased by the company. Without that connection, the plaintiff could not establish the required link or physical “nexus” between the website and a physical place of public accommodation.

Under Third Circuit law, the ADA does not automatically apply to every website simply because the website is accessible to the public. Instead, the law generally requires a connection, or “nexus,” between the website’s services and a physical place of public accommodation. Courts within the Third Circuit have taken different approaches to website accessibility claims, but Murphy reinforces the importance of this connection.

The District Court in Murphy emphasized that an ADA claim must show a connection between the physical place of public accommodation and the services the plaintiff claims were inaccessible. In other words, the fact that a website is allegedly inaccessible does not, by itself, establish a valid ADA claim under this legal standard.

It is abundantly clear that the Third Circuit has recognized that Title III ADA requirements protect more than mere physical access to buildings. The statute guarantees “full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations” of a place of public accommodation. This means that if a business operates both a physical location and a website, and the website denies access to goods or services connected to that physical location, a nexus may exist to support an ADA compliance claim.

For business owners, the key takeaway is that the connection between a website and a physical location can be critical to an ADA website claim in the Third Circuit. If a plaintiff cannot establish the required connection, the claim may fail as a matter of law. However, Murphy should not be read as a blanket exemption for online businesses or as a guarantee that a website accessibility lawsuit will be dismissed. Businesses should consider their specific operations and legal risks when evaluating their ADA obligations.

From a practical risk-management perspective, the Murphy litigation is part of a broader pattern. Numerous lawsuits alleging website inaccessibility have been filed in federal courts across the country, many by a relatively small number of repeat plaintiffs and law firms. As this pattern continues to expand nationwide, it is important for businesses to understand that the increase in these e-commerce ADA compliance suits are merely for the sole purpose of a shakedown of businesses to pay off bad actors instead of paying to defend the potentially frivolous suit. Business owners and their counsel should monitor ongoing developments in this area, as the legal landscape surrounding website accessibility continues to evolve. For businesses in the Third Circuit, Murphy reinforces that the connection between a website and a physical place of public accommodation remains an important part of the legal analysis.

If you have any questions about your website and its compliance with ADA and/or this judicial opinion, please contact Dan Lynch via our contact form or at 724-776-8000.

Schedule A Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

About Daniel P. Lynch

Daniel P. Lynch is the Founder of The Lynch Law Group, and has served as the Firm’s Managing Partner for over 20 years. In addition to leading The Lynch Law Group, Dan has been a practicing attorney for over 32 years and advocates for individual clients as well as businesses of varying complexities, including: small businesses, family owned businesses, and a range of middle-market companies and large corporations. Dan’s professional strength and experience include securities litigation, commercial litigation, employment law counseling and litigation, business succession planning, mergers and acquisitions, and general corporate transactions.